Hey! Welcome back to the Creator Economy NYC newsletter, your weekly stop for the people, ideas, and opportunities shaping the creator economy.

This week we’ve got an epic NYC creator business story to share with you: how a Substack publication with 17k subscribers and a team of two creators got acquired by Morning Brew.

This week: We sat down with Nate Rosen, founder of Express Checkout, to get the inside scope on how a pandemic Twitter habit turned into a creator-led media company Morning Brew wanted to own. (We also tried to get juicy details about deal terms. Trust us, we asked!)

Plus, our final event of the year below!

Let's get into it.

The follow-up might be the most underrated part of building your business

Whether you’re pitching brands, landing sponsorships or growing your business, most deals don’t die in the meeting. They die in the dead space.

That’s everything between your tools: the brand that said “circle back in Q1,” the contact who went quiet, the lead sitting in a spreadsheet. Your notes live in one app, your emails in another, your deals in a CRM, and the only thing connecting them is you.

That’s where Zig comes in.

Zig is your AI-native sales partner. It works across the tools you already use, catches what’s slipping, and handles the next step, from meeting prep and notes to personalized follow-ups and CRM updates.

Zig notices. Zig does. You approve.

Stop being the glue holding your stack together, and get back to building relationships.

Download the Zig.ai app from the App Store or Google Play and use code BRETT30 for 30 days free.

How a two-person newsletter got acquired by Morning Brew

Last month, Morning Brew Inc. acquired Express Checkout, a creator-led media brand covering CPG, retail, and the brands filling your fridge.

The all-cash deal gave Morning Brew 100% of Express Checkout's IP, and Nate and his co-founder, Jenna Movsowitz, joined the company full time.

The arc, in short:

  • 2020: Nate starts posting on Twitter during the pandemic

  • 2022: Substack launches

  • 2024: Jenna joins as a co-founder

  • 2026: a twice-weekly newsletter, a weekly podcast, social, and events, with around 17K subscribers at the time of the deal

The story of how Nate and Jenna grew Express Checkout into a hyper-niche media business with an engaged audience and massive exit is something all creators should be studying.

Here’s what to take notes on:

1. Build from the world you already know

Both Nate and Jenna come from a CPG Industry background. Nate first worked at a CPG startup during the pandemic, and then spent about two years at a fintech company doing lending for consumer brands.

Jenna was a friend from the New York CPG scene who knew the industry in and out. And both were working full-time jobs while they built Express Checkout on the side.

Nate first started building a presence on Twitter by connecting with people in the CPG world, sharing what he was working on at the startup, and gradually moving from DMs and comments to posting his own ideas. Eventually he had the idea of starting a newsletter mostly as a reason to stay up-to-date by everything happening in the industry.

❝

"I didn't feel like there was anything that read the way I wanted somebody to talk about this space."

So he built the thing HE wanted to read (which is solid advice for any creator trying to find their niche). At the same, he played to both his strengths and where he saw a gap in the market.

Express Checkout talks to industry people, but also to "a curious consumer, somebody who's interested in the world around them." (Industry people are consumers too, and most of them don't want to read technical stuff all the time.)

2. Get your audience on the email list early

One of Nate’s early lessons speaks to the cardinal rule of creator businesses: be intentional about building an email list.

The very first edition went out to 150 people or so, mostly friends and coworkers from Twitter.

From there, Nate published weekly, and his network started passing the newsletter around. Growth was almost entirely organic: readers shared it internally at their companies, while others found it through Google searches and Substack recommendations.

That doesn't mean every big moment on social translates to a bigger list. Nate told us one video about Kim Kardashian joining an energy drink brand went viral, but brought him only around 50 followers and no newsletter signups.

As he put it: “I got nothing out of going viral.”

It’s a great reminder that views are fun (and we love a viral moment), but they're not the same thing as an audience that comes back. Give people a reason to join your list, and keep showing up for the ones who do. By doing so, you’re creating an asset that’s holds value (maybe so much so that Morning Brew eventually comes knockin’ 👀)

3. Be strategic about when and how you bring on help

Every creator will eventually come to the same crossroads: do I try to do ALL of it myself (and slowly drown) or I bring on the help needed for the business to grow.

For Nate, that crossroads meant bringing on Jenna as co-founder.

It was a strategic move: Jenna was a great writer, knew the New York CPG scene inside and out, and would help grow the business in ways he couldn’t do on his own.

❝

"I think being a solo founder is crazy. I don't know anybody who should do that. It's really nice to have like just another person's opinion and another set of hands, another POV,” Nate said.

Jenna took on a big piece of the writing, which freed Nate to focus more on social and video, the part of the business he wanted to grow. Today she's a full one-to-one partner and very much a face of the brand.

That decision also changed what Express Checkout was (and how valuable it’d be to a company like Morning Brew).

As Nate explains it:

❝

"We're a creator-led media company. It's Jenna and I. We're the faces of it. We're everything."

Express Checkout is led by two people with personality, perspective and a deep level of expertise. And it's built something bigger than either of them.

Why Morning Brew bought it (and why now)

Nate and Jenna weren't looking to sell. They were figuring out how to keep growing, whether that meant bringing in investors or finding some other kind of support.

Morning Brew was a natural fit. It's been leaning into creator-led media (Adweek reports its creator-focused monetization is up more than 50% year over year), and Express Checkout filled a gap in their coverage. Morning Brew already has Retail Brew, but Express Checkout sits somewhere between consumer and B2B.

When we asked Nate what he was looking forward to most working with Morning Brew (other than the office pantry snacks), he said:

❝

“Officially starting a YouTube channel … a real YouTube channel with long-form videos that we produce that are not just our podcast uploaded.”

It’s the best of both worlds: Morning Brew’s resources can help power that next phase of growth, while Nate and Jenna stay in the driver’s seat of the brand.

❝

"We're still the stewards of the brand. Like, effectively, nothing has changed other than ownership. And we have some money in our pocket, which is great.”

Steal this: The niche-media playbook

  1. Start in the world you know. Your industry, your job, your obsession. Your expertise is the moat.

  2. Get people on the list from day one. It’s never too early to start getting those emails.

  3. Sell who's reading, not how many. Know your audience well enough to match them to the right sponsors. Express Checkout’s audience is valuable for its depth & niche and not because it reaches a massive amount of people.

  4. Bring on a partner who covers your blind spot. Best way to level up if you want to turn what you’re building into a company.

  5. Own a lane and a point of view. Find the empty middle, and skip the topics that aren't yours.

  6. Build something that can outgrow you. A brand bigger than one person is a brand someone can buy.

Thanks, Nate, for sharing the inside story. You should subscribe to Express Checkout here.

NEXT EVENT: December 9th - one last mixer before we wrap up 2026

Join Creator Economy NYC for our Creator Holiday Mixer, celebrating the end of the year and the launch of Launchpad by Hotmart.

Expect drinks, great company, and a conversation with some of NYC's top creators on finding your unique edge, standing out, and building a business around what makes you different.

Due to the nature of our venue, this is smaller than our usual events, so space is limited and attendance is by application.

Two minutes. A chance to win $150. 🎁

Earning money from your creator work? We want to hear how you manage it.

Complete our 2-minute survey for a chance to win one of three $150 B&H gift cards. Three winners will be selected at random.

Whether you’re just starting out, creating alongside a day job or doing it full-time, your experience belongs in this report. Individual responses stay anonymous in everything we publish.

Two free tools top creators use to keep themselves moving

The Creator Goal Setting Guide (FREE): A simple but powerful document to help you declare who you want to BECOME in 2026. Get it here.

The Creator Accountability System (FREE): Your visual companion for consistent creation in 2026. Get it here.

Thanks for reading! If Nate and Jenna's story doesn't hype you up about the value of what you’re building as a creator, I don’t know what well.

P.S. Morning Brew, if you’re reading this, you know where to find another great creator media brand. Our DMs are open. 👀

F*ck It, Create It,

Brett and Taylor

Comments

Avatar

or to participate

Keep reading